The James Webb Space Telescope has uncovered baffling new details about TOI-5205 b, a Jupiter-sized "forbidden" planet orbiting a red dwarf star only four times Jupiter's size and 40% the mass of our Sun. According to established models, such small stars should not be able to form or retain gas giants this large. A team led by Caleb Cañas at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center analyzed three transit observations and found the planet's atmosphere contains significantly fewer heavy elements than its host star — an unprecedented result among studied giant planets.
The data revealed methane (CH₄) and hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) in the atmosphere, along with a striking paradox: while the atmosphere appears metal-poor, interior modeling suggests the planet's bulk composition is roughly 100 times more metal-rich. This indicates heavy elements migrated inward during formation without subsequent mixing. "These findings have implications for understanding the giant planet formation process that occurs early in a star's lifespan," said Dr. Anjali Piette of the University of Birmingham.
The study, published April 6 in The Astronomical Journal, involved researchers from Carnegie Science, the University of Zurich, Johns Hopkins, and the University of Tampa. Dr. Shubham Kanodia of Carnegie Science noted the observations show "much lower metallicity than our models predicted," pointing to a very carbon-rich, oxygen-poor atmosphere unlike anything seen before.
